Did you know that one small log cabin in Red River carries the story of two pioneer families, a gold miner who became a farmer and freighter, and brothers who arrived in New Mexico in a covered wagon? The Melson-Oldham Cabin, now at Tall Pine Resort southeast of town off Highway 150, is a one-story, square single log pen built of square-hewn beams joined by half-dovetail notches. According to local tradition recorded by the National Park Service, it was originally built on the Red River City townsite, platted in 1895 about a mile and a half away, and was moved to its present site in the early 1900s by Tommy Melson.
Thomas Melson was listed in the census of 1900 as a 42-year-old gold miner from Iowa, and he and his wife, Mary, made the cabin their home. By 1910 he was listed as a farmer, and in the business directories of 1913, 1914 and 1915 he was listed as a freighter while Mary was listed as a laundress. The National Register nomination notes that his changing work shows the shift many settlers made from mining to other occupations as the boom subsided. When the Forest Service built the old Red River Pass road in 1914 to 1916 above his farm, his place served as a storage depot for construction equipment, and the supervising engineer remembered Tommy Melson, in his brown derby hat, grumbling as road material slid into his corn patch, but glad to get a decent road.
In 1920 the property was purchased by Nathan K. and Richard A. Oldham, twin brothers who operated a cattle ranch east of Raton. They had come to New Mexico from Missouri in 1874, with their father and brothers in a covered wagon. Their brothers Lowny, Morgan Read and George L. Oldham had come to Red River during the 1890s gold rush and had acquired claims with names like the Golden Treasure, the Golden Calf, Bunker Hill and Raton. The cabin bought in 1920 was also used by their miner brothers as housing in winter, joining the family’s mining years to its ranching years in one small building.
The Oldhams gave the place a new life that pointed toward the Red River visitors know today. In 1922 the brothers dug a fish pond near the cabin, and in summer the family used the property for recreation. During the 1920s they built a few sheds for rental to fishermen who came to use their pond, and from that beginning they developed Tall Pine Resort, which grew to dozens of tourist cabins scattered in the woods. A kitchen shed room was added at the rear, its log-slab siding made from the rounded refuse left after boards were sawn at local mills, a popular mountain building material.
When the cabin was listed on the National Register of Historic Places on February 23, 1984, as part of the Red River Multiple Resource Area, it was already being kept as a museum. The nomination describes it as a good example of the square single pen log cabin form in New Mexico and as a pioneer building type from Red River’s settlement years, significant for its association with the Melsons and the Oldhams, who were pioneer settlers of Red River. Partitioned into two exhibit rooms and filled with items pertaining to the history of Red River, the little 17-by-19-foot pen still teaches the lesson its families lived: first came the search for gold, then the steadier work of farming, freighting, ranching and welcoming fishermen, and that second work is what built a town.